From: Tom Brinkman (reportbase_at_[hidden])
Date: 2005-06-01 15:28:28
Andy Little wrote:
> Three positive reviews is not sufficient in my opinion. However,
> the precedent has already be set, as other libraries have been approved on
> a similar limited number of reviews.
>>Obvious questions in response to this...
>>How many reviews are sufficient?
>> What proportion in favour/against acceptance is acceptable?
The judgement of the library's review manager is the final determinent.
The criteria that he/she used to accept or reject the submission
should be clearly stated in the review managers report after the
review period is over.
Tom Brinkman